When it comes to skincare, especially for those dealing with acne or sensitive skin, one major concern is avoiding "pore-clogging" ingredients in their makeup and skincare. The traditional tool for assessing this risk is the comedogenic scale. For years this scale has been the go-to for determining whether or not a product is suitable for an acne-prone individual and whether or not they should use a product, but recent research shows that its reliability is more complex than it seems.
The Comedogenic Scale: Origins and Limitations
The comedogenic scale, introduced in the 1970s, ranks ingredients from 0 to 5 based on their likelihood to clog pores. However, these tests were initially conducted using rabbit ears, not human skin. Rabbit skin has different follicle structures and reacts more sensitively than human skin, often leading to misleading results. For example, an ingredient that causes comedones (pore blockages) in rabbits might not affect human skin the same way. Subsequent human testing, often performed on back skin, has further highlighted discrepancies because back skin differs significantly from facial skin in sensitivity and structure.
Why the Scale Isn't Always Accurate
Ingredient Interaction: Ingredients don't work in isolation. In a skincare formula, they interact, sometimes reducing or increasing each other's comedogenic potential. For instance, an ingredient deemed comedogenic alone might not pose a risk when combined with others in a well-balanced formula.
Concentration Matters: Even highly comedogenic ingredients may be harmless in low concentrations, something the scale doesn't account for.
Individual Differences: Skin reactions are highly individual. What clogs one person’s pores might not affect another’s. Factors like skin type, sebum production, and even environmental conditions play significant roles.
Modern Insights and Best Practices
Instead of solely relying on the comedogenic scale, consider these practical steps:
Know Your Skin: Understand how your skin reacts to common ingredients. Patch testing new products can help identify potential irritants. When testing a new product, apply it to a small section on one side of your face first to observe how your skin reacts. Give the new product a few days to gauge results.
Evaluate the Formula: Look at the overall product formulation, not just individual ingredients. Products with a mix of low-comedogenic components can still be beneficial.
Check Ingredient Order: Ingredients listed at the beginning are present in higher quantities. Pay extra attention to potentially clogging ingredients at the top.
Personalized Skincare is Key
While the comedogenic scale offers a starting point, it’s not foolproof. Skincare is deeply personal, and what works for one person might not work for another.
If you need help finding acne-safe products for your unique skin, book a consultation with Aeri Asethetics.
Comentarios